Whitehall experts slam Universal Credit performance 'reset'

Institute for Government queries decision of Major Projects Authority to give the Coalition’s beleaguered welfare a performance bye.

Whitehall experts have criticised the decision of civil servants charged with monitoring the performance of half a trillion pounds worth of Government infrastructure projects to give the Coalition's beleaguered Universal Credit programme a ‘reset'.

The news follows publication by the Cabinet Office's Major Project Authority of its second annual report into 199 major national schemes with lifetime costs of £488bn.

 
According to the Red-Amber-Green (RAG) ratings assessing the preparedness of these large-scale infrastructure schemes, half of the 30 projects faced with the most significant challenges last year have improved.
 
The number of in-house civil servants reviewing these schemes has increased to 87% after concerted efforts to embed in-house skills, the MPA reported.
 
Minister for the Cabinet Office, Francis Maude, said improvements to the running of major projects had helped saved £1.2bn in 2012/13.
 
‘All leaders of these projects will go to our new training school at the University of Oxford,' Mr Maude added.
 
But Gavin Freeguard a researcher at the influential Whitehall think-tank the Institute for Government noted: ‘The proportion of projects receiving a positive green or amber/green has gone down this year, and those receiving a red or amber/red rating has gone up.'
 
He added: ‘One disappointing note is that DWP's ‘resetting' of the rating for Universal Credit means there is no information updating its amber/red rating of 2013.'
 
According to the report, the DWP are now £300m behind schedule on development of the Universal Credit programme - which is designed to amalgamate six separate benefit payments into a monthly benefit that can be managed by claimants online.
 
He said: ‘With around £500bn of public money expected to be spent on these projects, it's vital that government continues to publish such realistic assessments so we can analyse what's happening in more detail.'
 
Mr Freeguard said the improvement in many of the projects that were rated red or amber-red last year was encouraging, but said it was vital the government continued to publish realistic assessments.
 
A spokesman for the Department for Work and Pensions said the ‘reset' for Universal Credit was not new and referred to changes the department jad announced in 2013.  The spokesman insisted it would not affect the roll-out of the single-payment welfare reform.
 

Some reel difference-makers

26 July 2024

Dozens of local authorities are investing modest sums in a fostering film project that could potentially save millions of pounds, as John Cooper explains.

PFI troubles ahead

By Caroline Mostowfi | 16 July 2024

Caroline Mostowfi outlines the challenges of Private Finance Initiative expiry and why it is time for councils to act now to proactively influence the way th...

Council housing landlords warn of £2.2bn 'black hole'

By William Eichler | 11 July 2024

Twenty of England’s largest local authority landlords have warned that the council housing financial model is ‘unsustainable’ with councils’ housing budgets ...

South Cambs' four-day week trial shows 'positive' results

By William Eichler | 08 July 2024

A report into South Cambridgeshire DC’s controversial four-day week trial found the majority of key performance indicators had improved or remained the same.

Jonathan Werran

Popular articles by Jonathan Werran