NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE

It makes good sense to diversify income

Some of the commentary on commerciality implies councils are going into these investments recklessly, and that is simply not the case, says Simone Hines. Continuing to be creative and innovative with council finances is going to be vital, she adds.

The commercialism debate rumbles on with the publication of the National Audit Office's (NAO) recent report and the Public Accounts Committee hearings in May. The reasons for councils making commercial investments are well rehearsed. We've long been encouraged to be more self-sufficient. Many district councils no longer receive Revenue Support Grants and have looked for new income streams.

These investments enable the risks to be managed at a local level and provide some protection from the shocks of reduced Government funding. The current pandemic has shown there is an over reliance on the main sources of income, and it makes good financial sense to diversify income. It should also be remembered that this is not new to us. Local authorities have invested in property for many years and there are legal powers.

S151 officers have a legal and professional duty to ensure the necessary due diligence has been undertaken prior to making a commercial investment – or any investment for that matter. Some of the commentary on commerciality implies councils are going into them recklessly, and that is simply not the case.

The current PWLB consultation muddies the waters even further by proposing that any authority undertaking commercial investment will not have access to PWLB. This risks undermining the prudential framework and local decision making. It may force s151s toward using riskier finance sources.

The NAO report referred to £6bn of commercial property acquisitions, but there may be wider reasons for these – such as town centre regeneration.

A handful of councils may have pushed the current prudential framework to its limits, but the arbitrary interventions being suggested are the proverbial hammer to crack a nut. Continuing to be creative and innovative with our finances is going to be vital – let's not make it any harder than it is already going to be.

Simone Hines is president of the Society of District Council Treasurers and executive director of resources at Nuneaton & Bedworth BC

NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE

London remade

By Jonathan Werran | 04 July 2025

London has a golden opportunity to reset and reform the relationship between its boroughs and the mayoralty. Just how bold and radical this reform will be de...

NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE

Common sense Reform

By Paul Marinko | 03 July 2025

Reform UK is taking a measured approach to implementing change as the party takes charge of Durham Council, the authority’s new leader tells Paul Marinko.

NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE

Could they be a contender?

By Jack Shaw | 03 July 2025

If Reform-controlled authorities prove dysfunctional or obstructive will that erode trust in both devolution and local government? Can their administrations ...

NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE

Top Talent: Regeneration and Growth

02 July 2025

As part of our regular series on ‘rising stars’, we celebrate the regeneration and growth officers who have been nominated by their councils for having an im...

Popular articles by Simone Hines