FINANCE

Two birds one stone on audit

The recommendation in the Redmond review to push back the accounts completion and audit dates is, in the view of Simone HInes, a backward step, 'a point the Society of District Council Treasurers made during the review process'.

There's no doubt the Redmond review is a thorough and in-depth study and pinpoints what we have known for some time – that the current audit system isn't working and needs to change. I still can't help feeling a little underwhelmed.

The recommendation to push back the accounts completion and audit dates is, in my view, a backward step, a point the Society of District Council Treasurers made during the review process.

Yes, the current timetable is ambitious and puts pressure on finance teams (especially for small finance teams in districts) but it means we can put them to bed early and crack on with more meaningful things – mainly the budget-setting process and vital projects such as town centre and housing schemes.

In districts it's the same key people closing the accounts who are also responsible for getting the budget-setting process under way in the summer, so dragging the accounts and audit process out until September is an unwanted distraction.

The real wasted opportunity from the review is streamlining of the accounts. The review found an almost unanimous view that the current statement of accounts are unfathomable to most readers, yet the only recommendation is to add another statement.

I partly understand the rationale behind this addition in helping readers interpret the difference between the complex statutory accounts and the actual financial position of the council, but adding a further statement is the wrong answer. It is even more work for finance teams and the need for the statement itself is further evidence that the current accounts are not fit for purpose.

Instead, a fundamental review of financial reporting in local government and what stakeholders are really interested in should be done. If we cracked this conundrum it might reduce the time needed to audit the accounts, so other issues around the timetable and fees may not be such a problem. Two birds, one stone.

Simone Hines is president of the Society of District Treasurers and executive director of resources at Nuneaton and Bedworth BC

FINANCE

Finance warning amid growth fears

By Joe Lepper | 13 March 2025

Pressures on local government could become more acute amid fears of ‘lacklustre’ growth, sector experts have warned.

FINANCE

LGR: What we must get right

By Emma McGowan | 12 March 2025

Emma McGowan feels the moves toward Local Government Reorganisation is a once in a lifetime chance to set things up differently for the next generation, crea...

FINANCE

Why first impressions count at the count

By Richard Baker | 12 March 2025

Mark Rogers and Richard Baker share lessons learned from a public affairs campaign that encouraged the East Midlands Combined County Authority region to come...

FINANCE

Council finance system 'not fit for purpose', MPs told

By Martin Ford | 11 March 2025

The system for turning around councils in financial distress is ‘not fit for purpose’ councillors have told MPs.

Popular articles by Simone Hines