Title

SOCIAL CARE

A system of finance that's ready for extinction

Heather Jameson says the current system of local government finance ‘looks more and more like it was designed by dinosaurs and is due for extinction’.

I once heard Kensington and Chelsea LBC chief executive, Barry Quirk, talk about evolution. The temptation is to think of a slow process, as we gradually evolve. But it is a misconception – evolution is not always a slow process. From the big bang to the dinosaur extinction, evolution owes more to swift catastrophic events than it does to incremental change.

The coronavirus crisis is the catastrophic event of our time. The impacts – economic, institutional, community and personal – will resonate for many years to come.

Any local government transformation plans underway before the pandemic – and the associated budgeted savings that went with them – are incremental compared with what is to come. Already, we have started to see the green shoots of ambition of a new deal for local government.

As central government responses look increasingly shambolic, local authority delivery on the ground looks far more impressive and the confidence of the sector is buoyed. There is already a new relationship across the public, community and voluntary sectors, boosted by necessity, but set to last into the future.

As Rob Whiteman told MPs this week, the crisis has exposed the gaping holes in council finances and the weakness of covering essential services – including social care – on the back of two meagre property taxes and a rag-bag of fees and charges.

More than ever, the limitations of local government autonomy have been tested. An initial promise from ministers to cover the costs of the pandemic, wavered – adding financial anxiety to an already arduous task. The sector is at the whim of a handful of ministers as local communities need more support than ever.

It's no surprise that the announcement of the latest tranche of cash caused a scramble of lobbying from different factions of the sector, arguing why they deserved more when we all know the truth: the problem is not the size of your slice, the cake is just not big enough.

Local government shouldn't have to go cap in hand to Government to cover the costs of a national emergency, to look after UK citizens at a local level. They should have control over their own tax-raising powers.

The current system of local government finance, of top down bureaucracy and central control, looks more and more like it was designed by dinosaurs and is due for extinction.

SOCIAL CARE

EXCLUSIVE: Whitehall–council secondment pilot agrees just five placements in a year

By Dan Peters | 19 November 2026

The sector is expected to urge ministers to make secondments between Whitehall and local government a genuine two-way exchange, as The MJ can reveal a govern...

SOCIAL CARE

Good governance starts with supporting the people behind it

By Hannah Cottam | 19 November 2026

Supporting Monitoring Officers to carry out their important role is crucial to future retention and recruitment, writes Hannah Cottam.

SOCIAL CARE

Giant steps to devolution and growth

By Henry Kippin | 19 November 2026

Henry Kippin shows how John Coltrane and other jazz greats can point the way to building state capacity at a local and regional level.

SOCIAL CARE

Keeping power close to people

By Dr Helen Paterson | 19 November 2026

In her second paper on the future of local government, Helen Paterson makes the case for devolution built on proximity, participation and representation.

Heather Jameson

Popular articles by Heather Jameson

-->