SCRUTINY

When robust scrutiny becomes unfounded abuse

Michael Burton says surely 'citizen journalists' should accept the same ethical standards as professional journalists, and he asks why 'unelected public servants' shouldn't have the same protection against unfair criticism granted to the public.

The case of Sandwell MBC which lost its High Court attempt to have an injunction issued against a local blogger raises a much wider question about how much abuse a council officer should be expected to endure, if any, from so-called ‘citizen journalists' or members of the public with bees in their bonnets about their council.

In this particular case the council intervened after a series of critical blogs and social media posts targeted against one of its directors who went public about her mental health issues. Dismissing the council's case, the judge said the blogger's comments were ‘puerile' but nonetheless ‘trenchant criticism' and therefore legitimate journalistic expression. The limits of criticism against ‘non-elected public servants', he added, were wider than those applied to private individuals. Or in other words, if you can't stand the heat get out of the kitchen.

Michael Burton

Popular articles by Michael Burton

SUBSCRIBE TO CONTINUE READING

Get unlimited access to The MJ with a subscription, plus a weekly copy of The MJ magazine sent directly to you door and inbox.

Subscribe

Full website content includes additional, exclusive commentary and analysis on the issues affecting local government.

Login

Already a subscriber?