Title

FINANCE

Blood out of stone

Opportunities to drive out further efficiencies from councils lie in prevention and integration, but 'will take time and investment and is unlikely to deliver any benefits until the back end of the Spending Review at the earliest', says Tony Kirkham.

When a colleague asked me what level of efficiency we should expect from local government over the next Spending Review period my initial response would not have been printable.

The phrase, ‘You can't get blood out of a stone' came to mind. The origins of this phrase seem to date back to 17th century Italy. The phrase in its various uses, such as ‘getting a drink out of Tom is like...' seems to suggest the reason why you can't do this is because Tom is unwilling. However, I would suggest if we apply the phrase to local government and the possibility of further efficiencies, the reasoning will not be down to willingness.

Local government has demonstrated time after time that it is the most efficient and effective part of Government, continuing to transform and deliver vital services to citizens during 10 years of austerity. Rising to the challenge of supporting people and business through the response to COVID-19 has surely only enhanced that reputation.

The ongoing response to the pandemic is consuming a lot of local government's energy and resources. The shortfall in Government financial support is not helping councils sustain their focus on the key issues to support their communities.

If we had the time and resources to drive out further efficiencies from local government, my view is any opportunities lie in prevention and integration. By involving and working with communities earlier in the cycle we can possibly reduce the cost to the public purse. By working with partners such as the NHS we can find better ways to support people and, given time, may prove more cost-effective. However, this approach will take time and investment and is unlikely to deliver any benefits until the back end of the Spending Review at the earliest.

Our supplies are running so low. Now is not the time to assume local government can make a further contribution to the national blood bank.

Tony Kirkham is director of resources at Newcastle City Council

FINANCE

Future Forum: Councils urged to embrace Total Place

By Martin Ford | 12 March 2026

Councils should seize the opportunity presented by ministers’ renewed interest in Total Place, according one of its pioneers.

FINANCE

Future Forum: Reorganisation threat to transformation

By Martin Ford | 12 March 2026

Fears that ambitions to include transformation alongside local government reorganisation may not be realised have been voiced at The MJ’s Future Forum.

FINANCE

Future Forum: SEND bail out risks disincentivising action says IFS

By Paul Marinko | 12 March 2026

The Government’s bail out of Special Educational Need and Disabilities (SEND) deficits risks discouraging councils from addressing the problem in future year...

FINANCE

Leaders united on devo despite reorg rivalry

By Neil Merrick | 12 March 2026

Council leaders in Hertfordshire have insisted they remain united over devolution despite presenting the Government with a range of options for reorganisation.

Tony Kirkham

Popular articles by Tony Kirkham