Title

FINANCE

The fantasy world of parties' spending pledges

Treasury select committee report on Autumn Statement is a sober reminder of the fiscal reality that belies pre-election spending pledges, writes MJ editorial director Michael Burton.

Now we are in election mode hardly a day goes by without one or all the political parties making yet another pledge on public spending despite the supposed dire state of the public finances.

A Treasury committee report however soberly reminds us that current government plans envisage cuts of 41% on non-protected government departments by 2020 which simply cannot be achieved without a huge impact on services.

The latest ‘mine's bigger than yours' on spending concerns education with Labour promising to stick to the Department for Education's £58bn budget ‘in real terms' each year to 2020. This follows the Conservatives promising to maintain the schools budget at the current per pupil level.

The Treasury select committee by coincidence produced its own report on last December's Autumn Statement on February 13. This reminds us that the Treasury's supplementary target, for public sector net debt as a percentage of GDP to be falling by 2015/16, continues to be a mirage; in fact the Office for Budget Responsibility has now for the fifth time in a row said this target will not be met.

Tax revenue is also failing to rise in line with GDP growth because most of the increase in employment has been at low pay level rather than in pay rises across the board. In fact you can see why the Prime Minister the other day exhorted employers to pay more because more pay means more tax income.

The MPs also recommend a study into the impact of immigration on wage levels which on the one hand has ‘held back' pay in the service sector, according to the Office for Budget Responsibility's evidence, but on the other also provides 35% of the NHS workforce without which it would be ‘in dire straits' (says the OBR).

Both the OBR and the Institute for Fiscal Studies argue that in the next five years 88% of fiscal consolidation will come from spending cuts and only 12% from tax rises. The government's plans envisage reducing total public spending to 35.2% of GDP by 2020 from a peak of 45.3% in 2009/10.

But the government also insists it will continue to ring-fence education, health and international development meaning cuts of 41% on non ring-fenced departments between 2010/11 and 2019/20.

In an under-statement Paul Johnson, IFS director, told the committee this would mean ‘significant change in the way things are delivered.' He favoured more crackdowns on welfare and tax avoidance.
 

FINANCE

Shaping councils' future destiny

By Neil Stewart | 16 November 2026

Local and regional authorities should stop waiting for central government to tell them what to do and start taking control of their own economic futures, wri...

FINANCE

Local authorities: Cash and care must go hand-in-hand

By Chris Cooke | 12 November 2026

Chris Cooke says greater local freedom must be matched by a sustainable approach to funding essential services and that will be especially important as the G...

FINANCE

Fiscal devolution: Roadmap is a good starting point

By Alex Walker | 04 November 2026

Alex Walker says fiscal devolution has started to take shape. But the destination should be more local freedom over tax rates and more revenue growth kept lo...

FINANCE

Fiscal devolution: Significant steps away from the centre

By Marcus Johns | 03 November 2026

Marcus Johns sets out the three key features of the Budget’s fiscal devolution roadmap and says the changes signal a future ‘where Britain escapes its status...

Michael Burton

Popular articles by Michael Burton

-->