Title

HEALTH

Who are the losers?

At least in terms of public opinion, local government itself has come out of the pandemic crisis better than the civil service, says Ben Page – with 55% saying local authorities did a good job compared to 47% for the civil service.

Who is having a good crisis? Medics and doctors remain much loved. The NHS walks on water. Boris Johnson remains better regarded than he was at the time of his election victory in December and Rishi Sunak, currently employing 9.3 million people in the private sector, has some of the highest ratings for any politician we have ever seen.

Keir Starmer has made a very good start, and has ratings similar to those of the young Tony Blair in 1994, although Labour remain behind in the polls, whereas Ed Miliband got 12 points ahead of David Cameron in 2010/15.

So far, the losers of the crisis – apart from the 1,000s of dead and their friends and relatives, the unemployed or soon-to-be unemployed – have been the charities, the businesses and public sector organisations whose income has disappeared.

This includes much of local government, already feeling the pinch, and likely to be squeezed again, and above all, care homes.

These are the organisations that come in for the most criticism from the public – in my view often through absolutely no fault of their own.

Looking across the public sector, 20% overall, and 32% in Scotland say they have handled the crisis badly, compared to 3% who criticise the NHS – which by all accounts often discharged people with the virus into care homes.

However, at least in terms of public opinion, local government itself has come out better than the civil service – with 55% saying local authorities did a good job compared to 47% for the civil service.

Of course, local government is routinely more trusted than central Government, but that doesn't seem to help it when it comes to handing out the cash, or getting any more devolution.

Dominic Cummings promises a ‘hard rain' for the Civil Service, but whether this trickles down in any positive way to local government, now dealing with the likely consequences of a sharp rise in unemployment, and an ever more needy ageing population, remains to be seen. And the pandemic is by no means over yet.

Ben Page is chief executive of Ipsos MORI

@benatipsosmori

HEALTH

Prevention, people and the future of public services in Wales

By Joanne Pitt | 05 December 2025

The idea of prevention being both necessary and achievable became a thread that ran through the CIPFA Wales conference, says Jo Pitt – and the event ‘made c...

HEALTH

Budget: The effects on combined and strategic authorities

By Tiffany Cloynes | 05 December 2025

Tiffany Cloynes looks at at the financial implications of the Budget for combined authorities and strategic authorities. She says that while the introduction...

HEALTH

Future Forum North: NHS Confederation chief says ICBs 'doomed' without thinking change

By Paul Marinko | 05 December 2025

The chief executive of NHS Confederation has said Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) are ‘doomed’ unless national thinking changes.

HEALTH

The final 15%: Why reaching every home with gigabit broadband matters

By Gráinne Gilmore | 05 December 2025

Gráinne Gilmore says the chancellor’s announcement of historic fiscal devolution – including £13bn of integrated settlements - gives local leaders unprecede...

Ben Page

Popular articles by Ben Page