ASSET MANAGEMENT

Selling the family silver is a mistake

The Government is Incentivising councils to sell off publicly-owned assets, 'but these flexibilities should not become business as usual and they are not a sufficient substitute for a reform of our broken funding system', warns Rob Whiteman.

Grounded in a reluctance to provide direct funding, the Government is incentivising councils to dispose of publicly-owned buildings and assets.

But selling the family silver to fund ongoing revenue costs is a terrible way to fix financial distress.

While we welcome greater flexibility handed to councils, the directive to break the rules of accounting convention marks an appalling shift from stable funding.

At best, disposing of assets to fund revenue shortfalls defers the impact of cost pressures on the general fund. In some cases these flexibilities risk exacerbating costs regardless.

This is unsustainable because it generates one-off cash injections that come with the burden of liability and borrowing costs, not to mention the loss of a potentially productive asset for the local authority.

In this way, there is a risk local authorities are drawn into fire sales in efforts to plug budget shortfalls. This could drive poor value for money for communities.

The Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) recommends flexibilities are limited to invest-to-save and uptake closely monitored. Independent reviews handled by a stakeholder panel including CIPFA and the Local Government Association could be an option.

Raising money in this way does not address longer-term pressures on finances and fails to target the underlying issue of how services are funded. The funding gap of £4bn, estimated over the next two years, can hardly be topped up by flexibilities on capital funding alone.

These flexibilities should not become business as usual and they are not a sufficient substitute for a reform of our broken funding system. The Government must set out what longer-term support will be provided. Only through such strategic and lasting measures can we safeguard the stability of our local government financing.

Rob Whiteman CBE is chief executive of CIPFA

X – @RobWhiteman

ASSET MANAGEMENT

If Surrey is straightforward, what does hard look like?

By Heather Jameson | 17 April 2025

When it comes to LGR Surrey is the hardest system to redesign, says Heather Jameson. 'With £5.6bn worth of borrowing, the rush to restructure is an attempt ...

ASSET MANAGEMENT

The outlook for Reform

By Paul Marinko | 17 April 2025

Paul Marinko finds that many share the view that Reform are going to do well in next month’s local elections. But what is likely to happen once they gain sea...

ASSET MANAGEMENT

Surrey urged to include single unitary proposal

By Paul Marinko and Heather Jameson | 17 April 2025

The Government has urged Surrey to provide costings for a single unitary authority in its final reorganisation plans despite its councils having rejected thi...

ASSET MANAGEMENT

LGA: 1,700 children referred to social services daily

By Paul Marinko | 17 April 2025

The Local Government Association (LGA) has revealed around 1,700 children are referred to social services every day, as it steps up demands for adequate fund...

Popular articles by Rob Whiteman CBE