WHITEHALL

Unitary 'mayhem' has failed to arrive thus far

The public may care often care a lot about key local services but aren't so interested in the structure of local government, says Ben Page. He expects councils' endless ability to just 'get on with it' on instructions from Whitehall will continue.

So far the lack of public interest in local government reorganisation is yet another reminder that while the public often care very much about key local services, they don't care so much about the structure of local government. Having seen its central government grant cut massively, the coup de grace for many councils is now merger and abolition. The public so far are not much engaged, or enraged, and certainly no more than the 5% who claim to know a great deal about local government, which roughly equates to those either working for, or in a household where someone works for, a council.

Local government remains as ever more trusted than central government – although that isn't a benchmark many might choose. Who now mourns Medina, Avon, Berkshire CC, Humberside, the Greater London Council and more? Efficiency and keeping council tax bills down will trump the number of people per councillor every time it seems. While people consistently support more local decision making in principle, this so far hasn't led to a majority voting in local elections, or protesting at a steady centralisation of control of many local functions. And while devolution in principle is popular, whenever the English are offered a local authority with devolved tax raising powers they reject it.

John Banham, running one of England's last reviews back in the 1990s, noted that a fully unitary solution for much of the country would commend all-party support in the House of Commons, but would cause ‘mayhem' when implemented. Successive governments have tended to the unitary principle, topped out with elected mayors, and so far mayhem has yet to arrive. I expect local government's endless ability to just ‘get on with it' on instructions from Whitehall will continue.

Ben Page is chief executive of Ipsos MORI

@benatipsosmori

WHITEHALL

Unlocking the power of data-sharing in local government

By Kathryn Lewis | 07 March 2025

Tim Pope and Kathryn Lewis look at how councils and Whitehall can look again at data-sharing to release its full potential

WHITEHALL

Sustainable regeneration: Looking back and moving forward

By Jessica Craig | 07 March 2025

The Government’s Plan for Neighbourhoods is not at the scale of the New Deal for Communities, but it can and should aim to emulate this success, says Jessic...

WHITEHALL

Making disruption work

By Dr Simon Kaye | 06 March 2025

The prize from local government reorganisation should not just be a ‘tidier map’ but a system built from the neighbourhood up to take on power and use it wel...

WHITEHALL

EXCLUSIVE: Stretched capacity slows pace of reorganisation

By Martin Ford | 06 March 2025

Small unitary councils are to be spared reorganisation until the map has been redrawn in two-tier areas, local government minister Jim McMahon has told The MJ.

Ben Page

Popular articles by Ben Page