WHITEHALL

The challenge of governing isn't just what, but how

Whoever wins the election, by whatever platform, their entry into office will quickly be met with the challenge of how to deliver on their promises in practice, says Jessica Studdert.

2024 will be dominated by the prospect of the most competitive election in recent times. Media attention will inevitably focus on what each party will offer as their policy platforms take shape.

What will Sunak's Conservatives do to retain his inherited Red Wall majority? By what strategy will Labour balance the need to be fiscally prudent yet distinct from the current Government? What will the Liberal Democrats do to break through?

But a deeper question for the country isn't just what the parties would do in office, but how they would do it. The limitations of our Westminster and Whitehall model have received attention recently – the Covid Inquiry laying bare the dysfunction at the heart of Government and outsourcing scandals demonstrating a cosy relationship with the private sector.

Yet discussion of the problems often majors on personality and partisan hype.

The underlying issue is that our rigid centralised governance system is simply not capable of responding with agility to the complexity of life in the 2020s.

Individuals entering high public office cannot rely on a statecraft through which a target is set, a lever is pulled, and an outcome delivered. Perhaps they never could, but in previous eras of more available public investment, the consequences were hidden – today they can't be ignored.

Our NHS is in meltdown, yet NHSE appears incapable of responding. Councils are on the brink of financial unviability, but this hasn't really registered as a problem in Treasury cost control calculations. Houses need building, and still the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities can't get funding out of the door.

Our top-heavy method of running the country is not fit for purpose. Whoever wins the election, by whatever platform they do so, their entry into office will quickly be met with another challenge: how to deliver on their promises in practice.

Jessica Studdert is deputy chief executive at New Local

X – @jesstud

WHITEHALL

Matching up to a new Government

By Paul Marinko | 16 July 2024

New LGA chair Louise Gittins tells Paul Marinko how she plans to pick up the pace to net the sector’s key asks of Sir Keir Starmer’s new administration

WHITEHALL

Crowdfunding's power to transform

By Frank Kibble | 15 July 2024

Frank Kibble looks at examples of how crowdfunding has been successfully used by local government and residents to champion projects that directly reflect lo...

WHITEHALL

So much to be done and it all starts now

By Heather Jameson | 10 July 2024

A commitment to devolve down must include regional, sub-regional, local and hyper-local government. It must drill down to communities that have long felt lef...

WHITEHALL

Unpicking what 'hard choices' means

By Caroline Green | 10 July 2024

Hard choices need to be not only about things we cannot afford in the short-term, but the things we cannot afford not to do in the long-term, says Caroline G...

Popular articles by Jessica Studdert