FINANCE

Climate for bolder restructuring

The Independent Commission on Local Government Finance’s report shares realistic solutions but doesn’t examine how local public services could be restructured in the interests of financial sustainability, argues Rob Whiteman.

During this period of austerity, the Government has shown little appetite for radical ideas that seek to adapt and enable local authorities to survive increasing pressures.

So, within the parameters, the Chartered Institute for Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) and the Local Government Association asked the Commission to recommend pragmatic solutions, that would not increase government spending but which would allow financial sustainability for public services. In this context, we are pleased that proposals have established a clear direction of travel that the Government should have the capacity to implement.

Within the review, one of the key recommendations made is that there should be an independent funding body. It would provide reassurance in the funding process between central and local government.

Within our manifesto we suggested a similar body under a different name – a grants commission. If it comes to fruition then we think it is paramount that it must exist in the long-term as a standing body which challenges funding allocations to ensure they can respond to local need and are adequate to fund the required activity.

As the Government edges closer to devolution, all authorities must be a part of this process. The Commission recommends that there should be pioneer areas that will be given additional devolved powers; however we feel these must represent a range of authorities, not just those who are already running similar models. Only by doing this we will be able to accurately evaluate the outcomes of these devolved powers.

If these recommendations were considered and adopted, then the climate of change could provide a unique opportunity for local authorities to go even further in restructuring.

The Commission's report, although sharing realistic solutions, doesn't examine how local public services could be restructured in the interests of financial sustainability. Within our manifesto we proposed other ideas, such as aligning services, to better achieve fiscal reform that would meet the needs of our communities.

Rob Whiteman is chief executive officer of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy

FINANCE

DCN: Alarming lack of evidence behind mega councils push

By Dan Peters | 31 January 2025

District councils have criticised the lack of evidence behind the Government’s push for new unitaries with populations of at least 500,000.

FINANCE

The great fiscal debate

By Martin Ford | 30 January 2025

Ministers have withstood calls for fiscal devolution, but with local government finances in crisis, pressure is mounting. Martin Ford reports.

FINANCE

Cantle: Councils should focus on community cohesion

By Emily Twinch | 30 January 2025

Councils should be left to concentrate on community cohesion with the Prevent radicalisation programme dealt with at a national level, according to the autho...

FINANCE

Questions over financial impact of reorganisation

By Martin Ford | 30 January 2025

Questions have been raised over whether the Government’s approach to local government reorganisation will help resolve the financial crisis facing the sector.

Rob Whiteman

Popular articles by Rob Whiteman