Title

HEALTH

Councils win legal battle with health boards

Health boards in Wales ‘misinterpreted’ the law over who is responsible for paying for nurses to deliver social care in residential homes, a court has ruled.

Health boards in Wales ‘misinterpreted' the law over who is responsible for paying for nurses to deliver social care in residential homes, a court has ruled.

The four-year legal dispute began when health boards in Wales decided to pay a flat weekly rate to nurses, excluding payments for non-nursing care time and for time such as supervised breaks.

Yesterday, the Supreme Court ruled in the 21 councils' favour, calling for the two parties to renegotiate the payments.

The Welsh NHS Confederation, on behalf of health boards in Wales, said it accepted the decision.

Vanessa Young, director of the Welsh NHS Confederation, said: ‘The judgement is the conclusion of a long and complex legal case, which was instigated by a legal challenge from the care sector.  

‘It has never been about winners or losers, but about seeking clarity on complex points of law and how they apply to the funding arrangements for those receiving nursing care in a care home setting.  

‘The outcome reflects the complexity of the case and the need for all parties to work together to agree the balance of responsibility for funding care in what is essentially a grey area of the law.'

 

HEALTH

The King's Speech must squeeze out more progress on climate

By Christopher Hammond | 11 May 2026

After a bruising local election, the King's Speech needs to bring local leaders and communities closer — not push them away, says Christopher Hammond.

HEALTH

New ADASS president's full in-tray

By Lee Peart | 11 May 2026

Newly elected president of the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services, Phil Holmes, shares his views on neighbourhood health, Integrated Care Boar...

HEALTH

Breaking point: Tough choices for childrens' services

By Martin Ford | 06 May 2026

Governments are finally confronting the spiralling cost of children’s services. As pressures intensify and budgets buckle, the real question is no longer whe...

HEALTH

Fifty years on: Lessons from the Layfield report on local council funding

By Owen Mapley | 29 April 2026

Half a century from the Layfield Report on local government finance, many of the issues it raised remain and have become more complex, says Owen Mapley.

Popular articles by Laura Sharman