ECONOMIC GROWTH

Wanted. New local governance structures

If the sector doesn't start building the locality of tomorrow today, and prefigure the final devolution settlement, central government will impose its own form, warns Simon Parker.

What would a game-changer look like for local government? We all know that councils are running out of money, and while I have a certain amount of faith in the ability of many parts of the sector to stagger on until the end of the decade, I am not sure we can go much further without something going seriously wrong.

There are really only three ways that an institutional disruption could go. One is to transfer substantially more power and funding to councils. Another is to take power and funding away. A third is to re-base the entire local government finance system.

The first approach would mean devolving a number of services that are only accidentally centralised to combined authorities: things like courts, prisons and perhaps even tax collection. 

But this probably does not go far enough. The most radical decentralisation would be a system in which local government commissioned the entire primary care budget and had to co-pay for hospital admissions, immediately creating a huge incentive for prevention.

The second would involve taking social care into the NHS, creating a sustainable local government system with a stroke of a civil service pen. However, we would also have created some of the weakest councils in the rich world. 

Finally, we are going to have to revisit the basis of local government finance. The current system has become so absurd and so manifestly unfair that it cannot simply be patched up for much longer.

If some form of game-changer is starting to look inevitable, the form of that change is not. 

We need to kick-start a national debate, that is not currently taking place, about the role of the local in British politics. And councils need to prefigure what an eventual devolved settlement should look like by starting to build new governance structures locally. 

If you don't build the locality of tomorrow, someone else will impose it upon you.

Simon Parker is director of the New Local Government Network (NLGN)

ECONOMIC GROWTH

Fiscal devolution: No risk, plenty of reward

By Heather Jameson | 14 March 2025

Is mayors' lobbying hiatus on fiscal devolution the right decision, asks Heather Jameson.

ECONOMIC GROWTH

Minister: 500,000 figure for unitaries an 'average'

By Paul Marinko | 13 March 2025

Jim McMahon has said a population size of 500,000 could end up as the ‘average’ when unitary government is completed across the country.

ECONOMIC GROWTH

Hampshire hits reorganisation deadlock

By Dan Peters | 13 March 2025

No decision will be made on the number of unitaries that will cover Hampshire and the Solent ahead of the deadline for interim reorganisation plans.

ECONOMIC GROWTH

Frustrated mayors delay campaign on fiscal devo

By EXCLUSIVE by Dan Peters | 13 March 2025

Labour mayors frustrated by the lack of fiscal devolution are holding back from stepping up their lobbying, The MJ understands.

Simon Parker

Popular articles by Simon Parker