COMMUNICATIONS

There is an opportunity to dump the centralist approach

Tackling the coronavirus crisis has been held back by a ‘central government know best’ approach, says Heather Jameson.

Even the most ardent supporter of the current government would probably be struggling right now to provide a positive appraisal of the government's performance throughout the coronavirus pandemic.

At best, it has been misguided and miscommunicated – too late to lockdown, too vague on what that means. At worst it has been dangerous, with far too many dead. Care homes have suffered in the effort to clear the decks and protect the NHS – the most vulnerable to COVID-19 have seemingly been exposed.

Running throughout the stories in The MJ this week – and every week since the pandemic started – is a clear theme: Tackling the coronavirus crisis has been hampered by a ‘central government knows best' approach.

From shielding to PPE purchasing and distribution, from tracking and tracing to harnessing volunteers, central government, although notoriously bad at direct services, has assumed no one is better placed to deliver than Whitehall – or perhaps the NHS at a push.

Over and over again, the government has reinvented the wheel, creating makeshift systems that would work far better at a local level – and then they have failed to communicate, to pass on information and to trust councils to deliver. Centralism has prevailed over common sense.  

Money is no object when it comes to protecting the NHS, providing Whitehall with resources, even bankrolling business with the furlough scheme – all of which are extraordinarily important and worthy of funding. But when it comes to financially supporting councils to protect their residents and communities, house the homeless and shore up plummeting tax income, a deep mistrust of local government returns.

We are just two months into a crisis that is set to reverberate on the country – and the economy – for years to come. As the initial emergency eases, lockdown lifts and we start to rebuild, there is an opportunity to dump the centralist approach and start to think about collaboration.

Getting people back out into their communities, onto high streets and back to work will happen at a local level. Rebuilding the economy will need to be done in our cities and towns.

Now could be the chance for central government to let go of the levers, work with local government and rebuild from the bottom up.

COMMUNICATIONS

Goodbye to all that

By Martin Ford | 20 December 2024

Ann McGauran and Martin Ford take a look back at the highs and lows of a pacy and action-packed year for local government.

COMMUNICATIONS

Barnsley builds on its housing success

By Sarah Norman | 20 December 2024

Barnsley MBC’s achievement of the highest consumer standards grading in the Regulator of Social Housing’s inspection underlines the collective efforts of the...

COMMUNICATIONS

When an inspector calls

By Angela Holden | 20 December 2024

Angela Holden looks at the emerging findings from the first social housing inspection judgements and sets out what can be done to improve the quality of soci...

COMMUNICATIONS

Rallying for a more balanced Britain

By Susan Jarvis | 20 December 2024

The mayors of Liverpool and Manchester’s ambition for the two city regions to work more closely together was one of the key themes of the annual Heseltine In...

Heather Jameson

Popular articles by Heather Jameson